The Mill House Inn has been called one of the Top 10 Inns in the Hamptons by New York Magazine, one of the Top 50 Small Hotels by Zagat’s, one of the 10 Most Romantic Inns by American Historic Inns and one of 15 Amazing B&Bs Worth a Plane Ticket by the Huffington Post. We’ve been the featured Inn of the Month in Travel+Leisure and the Destination of the Month in Harper’s Bazaar. Recently Conde Nast Traveler named us to its prestigious “Top Ten” Hotel List.
But as much as we love being recognized in the media (and we really, really do!) it’s the feedback from our satisfied guests that means the most to us. Our whole purpose is to give our visitors an unforgettable experience. And when we know we’ve succeeded, nothing feels better.
Scrolling above are a few comments our guests have shared with us. And below are our most recent examples of praise in the press. Check them out, then come stay with us to see for yourself what all the fuss is about!
In East Hampton, a hidden gem reminds us that breakfast really is the most important meal of the day.
–Edible East End
We also like the intimate Mill House Inn, a tiny 10-room retreat known for its incredibly sumptuous breakfast — yes, there’s lobster involved.
–Forbes Travel Guide
This inn’s breakfast has made a name for itself as one of Long Island’s most indulgent; don’t leave without sampling the lobster frittatas and crayfish and andouille étouffe omelets.
Suites are beautifully appointed at this central East Hampton outpost; refrigerators are stocked with homemade dog food. Human breakfasts with brioche French toast and lobster frittatas are worth the visit, and fresh-pressed juices are available.
–The Hollywood Reporter
Mill House Inn prides itself on personal service. Front desk attendants are more like full-time personal assistants, ready to suggest a screening of a vintage Elvis film at the Bay Street Theatre and arrange for a cab to deliver you there.
Fresh baked cookies, 10 uniquely designed rooms and homemade breakfasts with much-raved about dishes like lobster frittata make Mill House Inn feel more like a home than a hotel. When you’re not sampling a coffee flight or resting in rooms with stunning views of Old Hook Mill, head to nearby beaches, Guild Hall and The Stephen Talkhouse. Bonus: bring the pup. Mill House Inn is dog friendly.
The 10-room Mill House Inn in East Hampton has top-tier hotel service and amenities that will convert any and all remaining B&B skeptics.
“What makes The Mill House really special is the staff. They make sure you have everything you need or could possibly want. One night we were commenting on the strawberries, and they quickly offered up chocolate covered strawberries for us the following night. I mean…. come on! Ridiculously over the top nice. Nothing seemed too difficult or burdensome. Definitely will come back!” –TripAdvisor
“I travel a lot, to high end hotels around the world, and here’s what you have which I haven’t even experienced at the Shangri-La in Bangkok – when I walk in the door here there is such an overwhelming feeling of being welcomed. You have really mastered hospitality. Every little touch has been thought about, down to the water and the coffee which are absolutely amazing. It’s very special and that’s what will make me come back.” –Karen
“We have done the whole B&B tour today, but we saved you guys for last. You are our favorite place (also why we are staying here again). After going to all the different B&Bs around, we now see why we come to you for our visits. Your staff, personalities, service and attention to detail is far beyond any of the other places. This is a lot for me to say because I don’t like talking bad about places, but I felt it was important to let you know!” –Norman
THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMPLIMENTS!
I would choose to stay here instead of the Waldorf Hotel.
I am ready to call it a night and get in the most comfortable bed I have ever stayed in!
I feel like a princess, I’m getting so spoiled!
This is perfect! This is so great for us and our dog & it’s just so cute!
I have to say you guys are the only ones who truly get it. You literally do everything right here it’s refreshing.
Many thanks. I had such a nice time with you guys. I will only stay at The Mill House Inn.
ABOUT THE ART OF HOSPITALITY…
WOW! I have stayed from Montauk to Riverhead, you are by far, the most hospitable place I have ever been.
I remember being here years ago and it always reminds me of the amazing staff.
We’ve stayed at a lot of bed & breakfasts; you guys have given it all to us the moment we stepped in the door. Hot chocolate, cookies and a warm welcome, we love it here!
Oh, I have an air bath, did you know that Benjamin Franklin took air baths?
A steam shower sounds like exactly what I’m going to need!
ARE YOU HUNGRY?
Breakfast was amazing. Please tell the Chef I am sorry I couldn’t finish.
You’re infamous for your cookies!
The coffee is really good! I came for the coffee! This is fantastic, I have found a new favorite blend!
The breakfast was delicious and the vegetables are so fresh. I love the green juice, it’s all amazing.
With a pregnant wife… your snack bar, ice cream and popcorn have been my savior!
IT’S SO EASY TO SAY HELLO! AND OH, SO HARD TO SAY GOODBYE…
Do people ever leave? This is so great!
We are having such a wonderful time here! When we are ready to go home, would it be ok if we just take you all back home with us?
We have been here so many times before we probably know the check-in process as well as you do! We are definitely happy to be back.
It is so great to be back, I have been waiting for this moment. I am so happy I was able to get the room that originally turned me into a Mill House Inn lifer!
This is going to be the greatest weekend I have had in a long time!
We have never been to Long Island. Then we came across your Inn online and it was so lovely, we just had to stay with you.
We stayed in your lovely hotel a few years ago and are planning another trip to the US. We would love to come back to you; since we have been remembering your lovely hotel ever since!
It kind of feels like we are leaving home.
We are looking forward to our trip, we stay all the time and can’t wait to see you all!
We had such a great day! A nice walk on the beach with the dog, a relaxing sleep, it’s been so nice! We are so sad that we have to leave tomorrow, but we really needed this trip, my daughter and I. Thank you so much for everything!